Main Menu

We are an online storefront.    Our pastry kitchen is open for order pick-ups only.

To order call: Clare (317) 730-6802

or send email to:  clare@whimsicalwhisk.com

Order by the dozen of the same kind- no mixing or half orders.

*Item can be shipped

Hearty Cookies: $25/dz

*Awesome Colossal : Our Top Selling Cookie!- An awesome combination of peanut butter, chocolate and oatmeal

*Campfire: Selected as Snack of the Day in 2007 for the Rachel Ray Show, this is a rich combination of pecans, coconut, 2 kinds of chocolate…it is the kind of cookie you don’t share- it is that good.

*Candied Sweet Potato Cookie : A favorite amongst many locals- Made with freshly baked sweet potatoes, pecans, and finished with a rich maple icing.

*$19/dz Double Chocolate Chip:  A Soft buttery chocolate chip cookie, simple yet amazing.

$18.75/dz Snickerdoodle: Our Snickerdoodle is unlike any other you will taste. Our version of the Snickerdoodle cookie incorporates 2 key ingredients, highlighting Indiana agriculture. So, it is more than just a State cookie, instead it represents the State of Indiana.

 

The Chocolate Fix: Voted Best Brownies Ever! 1 dozen minimum

* $23.50/dz Killer Truffles This a cross between a truffle and air. Yes air because when devoured at room temp it collapses in your mouth. These are cut larger than the truffle. It is dark chocolate and pecans soaked in a liqueur. The longer they sit the better they are.

*$41/dz Chocolate Stud 3 kinds of chocolate and no nuts- It is incredibly moist, wet and full of chocolate.

*$41/dz Rocky Mountain Brownie Moist, dense, fudgy, chocolaty, and rich. A combination of walnuts, 2 kinds of chocolate and marshmallows

$45.50/dz Turtle Brownies Moist, dense, and very fudgey brownie with a generous layer of caramel and toasted pecans

 

The Flats: Amazing pastries fit for breakfast, the ride to school, afternoon snack, for dessert w/ a scoop of ice cream, or with a late night cup of tea.

1 dozen Minimum

*$37.50/dz Blackberry Flats Thin layers of pastry filled with blackberry jam, spice, and pecans

$37.50/dz Muddy Raspberry Flats Thin layers of pastry filled with chocolate and raspberry jam

*$38/dz Apricot Almond Flats Thin layers of pastry filled with apricot jam,  almond paste, almonds, and cinnamon sugar

 

Tea Cookies: 2 dozen minimum

*$12.50/dz Mexican Wedding Cake: These are so darn good.  Pop in your mouth and the powdered sugar coats your mouth releasing the butter pecan taste- delicious!

$12.50/dz Lemon Drops : Lemon poppy seed wafer filled with lemon cream

$15.75/dz Island Wafer Creams: Lime cookie with a key lime cream filling

$16.50/dz Lavender: A Lavender shortbread filled with a fresh lemon cream.

$18.75/dz Poker Dice: Dice shaped and lightly spice with a port and cream filling

*$18.75/dz Amaretto Balls: Not a cookie, cake or truffle but somewhere in between.  If you love almonds, chocolate, and amaretto then you will love these very addictive confections. Please order 3 days prior to pick-up

$15.75/dz Chocolate Pecan Thumbprints: Chocolatey, rich little butter cookies, with pecans and a generous dollop of chocolate ganache on top.

*$15.75/dz Sugar Ribbons : A sugar cookie texture, rich in vanilla and topped vanilla sugar

$23/dz Chocolate Pecan Biscotti: This is your traditional, hard, yet crispy and full of  flavors like espresso, pecans, and chocolate.  Perfect for dunking into coffee, hot chocolate, or a tall glass of milk.

We accept credit cards.